Longer Than the Great War

Longer Than the Great War
Photo by Sonia Dauer / Unsplash

In the next week, Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine will have lasted as long as the entire First World War.

On or about 10 June, a number will tick past without ceremony or commemoration. Measured from the morning of 24 February 2022, when Vladimir Putin announced his "special military operation," the full-scale war in Ukraine will have run for 1,567 days. That is the exact span of the First World War, from the guns of late July 1914 to the armistice at the eleventh hour of 11 November 1918. From that point on, every further dawn over the Donbas carries the conflict past the duration of the war that an earlier generation hoped had been dreadful enough to end all the others.

Begin from the true starting line, and even that comparison falls short. The fighting did not begin in 2022. It opened in the last days of February 2014, with the seizure of Crimea and the manufactured insurgency in the east. By that reckoning, the war is now in its thirteenth year, and it overtook the Great War long before most of the world had begun to take notice. The 2022 date is simply the one that lines up cleanly with the calendar, the phase that history will likely record as the main event.

I should be careful, because a comparison like this can be stretched too far. The First World War compressed an almost ungraspable toll of death into those same 1,567 days. Whole cohorts of young men were fed into the machinery of the Somme and Verdun and Passchendaele, and a continent spent a generation in mourning. Ukraine's losses are severe, with Russian casualties by several estimates now running past a million killed and wounded, and Ukrainian losses heavy though harder to count, yet this is not the industrial concentration of slaughter that defined 1916. What follows compares duration and character. It is not an attempt to rank the dead.

In terms of duration and character, the echoes are real. Trench warfare has returned to the European continent, something most planners had assumed they would never see again. The front has congealed into fortified lines, dugouts and tree lines and shattered villages, fought over for months at a stretch. Ground is measured in metres and in single settlements rather than in provinces. The pattern through 2026 has been one of grinding attrition for almost no reward: Russian forces gained only a few square kilometres across the whole of May, and Ukraine has largely halted Moscow's spring and summer offensive. Analysts at the Institute for the Study of War describe a front that has stabilised, while the RUSI Senior Fellow Dr Jack Watling has gone further, arguing that the war has reached a turning point as Russian combat performance wanes. The arithmetic is the same arithmetic that horrified the General Staff of 1916. Vast expenditure of life for almost no movement, and no decision in sight.

Where the two wars part company is in the workshop. The First World War was itself a violent hinge in military history, the moment the machine gun, poison gas, the tank and the aircraft turned killing into an industrial process. Ukraine is performing the same function for our own century, and the central instrument is the drone. The first-person-view quadcopter, assembled from hobbyist parts for a few hundred pounds, can now destroy armour worth several million. Loitering munitions hunt across the contact line while fibre-optic models fly beyond the reach of jamming. The electromagnetic spectrum has become a battlefield in its own right. Ukrainian deep strikes reach Russian refineries and the approaches to St Petersburg, delivered by weapons that did not exist in serious numbers four years ago. Above all of it sits the contribution from my own corner of this field: commercial satellite constellations providing connectivity and imagery at a scale no military ever planned for, helping to make the battlefield almost transparent. A soldier who moves can be seen, and a soldier who is seen can be struck within minutes. That is a different war from the one of barbed wire and field telephones, even when the trench lines look identical from the air.

None of this stays in Ukraine. Every military with the budget to care is studying the footage and adapting to it. Consumer drone technology has forced a rethink of how armour survives, or whether it can. The contest to control the electromagnetic spectrum has become a discipline in its own right. And feeding satellite imagery straight into a firing solution, so that a vehicle's movement and its destruction are minutes apart, is now taught in every serious staff college.Beijing and Washington are watching the same battlefield we are. Whatever settlement eventually arrives, the character of war has already changed on these fields, much as it changed for the twentieth century on the Western Front.

There is a quieter discomfort in the milestone, too. The First World War is woven into our collective memory. It gave us the poppy and the cenotaph, the two minutes' silence, the war memorials in British towns and villages and the poets whose lines we still recite. It became a permanent warning. Ukraine, for all that it has now lasted longer, is in danger of becoming something far worse than a warning. It is becoming routine. The nightly barrages, the casualty figures, the maps with their barely moving lines, all of it slides towards the background of the news, a war we have learned to live alongside. A conflict of this length on European soil should never be allowed to feel ordinary, and the fact that it increasingly does is its own kind of defeat.

The war that was meant to end all wars did nothing of the sort. It set the terms for the one that followed, and for the century after that. The lesson of long wars is that they reshape the world that comes next even more thoroughly than short ones do, because there is simply more time for the change to take hold. So when the counter passes 1,567 in the coming days, it is worth marking, because the length itself is telling us something. The world that emerges from this war will have been shaped by every one of those days. The least we owe the people living and dying through them is to keep counting, and to keep paying attention.